Pellevoisin (Indre department, France)
14 February to 8 December 1876
Our Lady at Pellevoisin: "I am all merciful"
Estelle Faguette, a thirty-three-year-old maid, was seriously ill. She wrote a prayer to the Virgin Mary, asking to be cured. Mary appeared to her in her bedroom on 14 February 1876: Estelle was miraculously healed a few days later and continued to see the Virgin, "Mother of all mercies", on several occasions that year. Mary entrusted her with the mission of spreading the scapular of the Sacred Heart, giving new impetus to the devotion to the Sacred Heart, which St Margaret Mary Alacoque had already promoted in the 17th century.
Les raisons d'y croire :
- It is strictly impossible to associate Estelle's pathology (severe lung lesions) with a psychosomatic illness.
After examining Estelle, who was suffering from chronic peritonitis that had degenerated into tuberculosis, Dr Bucquoy, a professor of medicine, thought that she had no chance of recovery. A few hours before the apparition, Estelle was at her worst, "no longer seeing, no longer eating, 'as if dead'". However, she was cured on the night of 18 to 19 February 1876, which is scientifically inexplicable.
Estelle was healed precisely on the day prophesied by the apparition, 14 February 1876: "You will suffer five more days, in honour of the five wounds of my Son". Insofar as Estelle's illness was not feigned and would in all probability end in her death, it is impossible for Estelle to have known of her own intelligence if and when she would recover, unless it had been revealed to her supernaturally.
- Estelle had no inclination toward fame, adulation, or media hype. She led a life of great discretion, kept her job as a maid and showed constant humility and obedience until her death. Her apparitions were not motivated by a need for recognition.
- Some people believe that the apparitions were due to Estelle's failing health. However, there is nothing in these apparitions to suggest that they were hallucinations: their duration (much longer than such psychotic episodes would be), the clarity of the messages, Mary's physiognomy (clothing details and the subtlety of the successive expressions on her face), the visionary's inner peace, the interactions between Estelle and the apparition (a real dialogue between two people, perfectly clear linguistically), the respect of the laws of optics (the size of the apparition varied according to whether it was moving away from or towards Estelle), etc.
- All the messages from the Virgin collected by Estelle are absolutely in accordance with the teaching of the Catholic Church: they cannot be the fruit of a fanciful mind. The devotion of the scapular has been well known in the Christian world since the 13th century (Carmel).
- What's more, a prophetic vision of Estelle's came true: on 6 February 1878, in ecstasy, she saw Archbishop Luigi Pecci of Perugia, dressed in white, to whom she handed a scapular similar to the one the Virgin was holding during the fifteenth apparition. Thirteen days later, Archbishop Pecci ascended the throne of Saint Peter as Leo XIII and, on 17 February 1900, he received Estelle in private audience. The Virgin Mary had also announced during her apparitions in 1876 that Estelle, a humble servant, would one day meet the Pope in person.
- The fruits of the Marian shrine at Pellevoisin are very significant: conversions, religious and priestly vocations, large numbers of confessions, healings, and so on.
- For almost 150 years, nothing has ever interrupted pilgrimages to the shrine of Pellevoisin: neither wars, nor economic and social crises, nor the vagaries of public life, nor any decision by the episcopal authorities.
- Although the Church has not yet formally and canonically ruled on the authenticity of these apparitions (the procedure is still pending), devotion to Our Lady of Pellevoisin is widely encouraged. Since 1876, the Church's support has been clear: the supernatural nature of Estelle's healing was recognised (in 1983, by the archbishop of Bourges Paul Vignancour); the development of the shrine and pilgrimage was encouraged; the scapular of Pellevoisin was approved by decree (by the Congregation of Rites, in 1900); and Estelle's cause for beatification was opened in 2020.
Synthèse :
Estelle Faguette, born in 1843 in Saint-Memmie, near Châlons-sur-Marne, France, became a servant in the household of Countess Marie-Luce de La Rochefoucauld-Montbel, in Pellevoisin, when a bad fall forced her to leave the novitiate of the Augustinian Sisters of Notre-Dame de Paris and give up religious life. Since 1875, however, she had been suffering from chronic peritonitis, which was poorly treated and consequently turned into tuberculosis. In February 1876, Estelle had been bedridden for several days and was in a great deal of pain.
Around midnight on 14 February, the Virgin Mary appeared to her. "I was trying to rest when suddenly the devil appeared at the foot of my bed. Oh, how frightened I was! He was horrible, he made faces at me; no sooner had he arrived than the Blessed Virgin appeared on the other side." So begins Estelle's story. The young woman, of very modest origins and the daughter of a bankrupted businessman, had never before reported the slightest extraordinary experienced. She led a secluded existence, far removed from the world, which she avoided like the plague. The presence of the grimacing being may seem anecdotal, or a figment of the imagination. In reality, it reveals the spiritual battle being waged around the sick woman, who had been told by a few people that her illness was terminal. Beyond the symbolic reference to the devil, and its figurative aspect, this evil spirit conveys the importance of the moment Estelle was living through, on the threshold of death.
The description she gave of the Mother of God is as follows: "She had a very white woollen veil that formed three folds; her features were regular, her complexion white and pink, rather a little pale." A dialogue then began between Estelle and the apparition: "Have no fear, you know you are my daughter. Courage, be patient, my Son will let himself be touched. You will suffer for five more days, in honour of the five wounds of my Son. On Saturday, you will either be dead or healed." The initiative came from the apparition, establishing contact between the humble young woman and Heaven, just as God so often takes the initiative to call people in the Bible. Mary soothed Estelle, removing the fear caused by the presence of the devil, a troublemaker and a source of unease, which vanished with the mere presence of the Virgin Mary, as confirmed by Christian tradition. In the weeks that followed, the apparition repeated: "I am all mercy".
The allusion to the five wounds of Christ was not an invention of the visionary: it is a devotion practised since at least the 11th century (Saint Peter Damian, d. 1072). Expressed in this way, it is impossible that Estelle, whose religious knowledge was very limited, could have invented such a formula.
Fourteen other apparitions followed one another until 8 December 1876, in the same place, namely Estelle's bedroom. On the night of 18 to 19 February (fifth apparition), when she was thought to be on the point of death, Estelle was miraculously cured of her tubercular lung lesions.
On 9 September (ninth apparition), Mary showed her "red heart" (cf. the devotion to the Immaculate Heart of Mary, practiced the Church since Saint Bernard of Clairvaux and the private revelations made to great mystics, such as Saint Gertrude of Helfta at the end of the 13th century). The following messages evoke the difficulties encountered by believers in France during the Third Republic, where positivism and materialism sometimes reigned supreme.
On 8 December 1876, the day of the fifteenth and last apparition, the Virgin asked Estelle to wear the scapular she had shown her: "I have chosen you to spread my glory and to spread this devotion; you yourself will go to the prelate and present him with the model of the scapular [...]. Nothing would please me more than to see this livery on each of my children, and that they will all apply themselves to repairing the outrages that my Son receives in the sacrament of his love." "Show it to the Pope?" the humble maid naturally wondered. She knew neither Rome nor even the rest of France... In fact, she did bring the scapular to Leo XIII when they met in private audience 24 years later.
From 11 April 1876, Father Salmon, Estelle's spiritual director, informed the diocesan clergy of the successive apparitions. The ball was rolling. The news quickly reached the ears of the Archbishop of Bourges, Charles-Amable de La Tour d'Auvergne. Father Salmon was authorised to speak about the events from the pulpit. The following month, the archbishop wrote that he had no problem with the words of the apparition being written on a sign ("I am all merciful), which would be placed above the statue of Our Lady of the Sacred Heart, in the church at Pellevoisin, and that Estelle's room should be transformed into a "little oratory", as it was there that the visionary was cured, having announced the date of this miracle in advance (on the night of 18 to 19 February, i.e. effectively five days after the previous apparition which had specified the moment: "You will suffer another five days"). This marked the beginning of the shrine at Pellevoisin and the pilgrimage that went with it.
On 13 January 1877, a commission of enquiry was set up to investigate Estelle's sudden recovery. Its conclusions were all favourable, as was Pope Pius IX's reaction to the proposed confraternity in honour of Our Lady of Pellevoisin. The confraternity was instituted on 28 July 1878 and raised to archconfraternity status in 1894 by Pope Leo XIII. From the outset, the papacy and bishops supported the devotion to the scapular of Pellevoisin.
On 6 February 1878, the day before the death of Pope Pius IX, Estelle had a prophetic vision: she saw the future pope (a "bishop dressed in white") in the guise of Pius IX's successor, who would be elected thirteen days later and ascend the throne of Saint Peter under the name of Leo XIII. The pontiff received Estelle in private audience on 17 February 1900.
On 4 April, the Roman Congregation of Rites published a decree approving the Pellevoisin scapular. From then on, there was no stopping the thousands of faithful who came to Estelle's room, which had been transformed into a place of prayer.
By the time of Estelle's death on 23 August 1929, the Church had not yet ruled on the supernatural origin of the apparitions, but the diocesan authorities were organising the nascent shrine by entrusting it to nuns and religious. In 1983, Archbishop Paul Vignacour of Bourges officially recognised the miraculous nature of Estelle's healing. In 2009, a "Centre Estelle Faguette" was opened, where formation, prayer sessions, retreats and other events are organised every year. Finally, in June 2020, Archbishop Jérôme Beau of Bourges had the joy of seeing his project to reopen the cause for the beatification of the visionary accepted by all the members of the French Bishops' Conference.
Aller plus loin :
Pellevoisin: Our Lady Reveals the Devotion of the Sacred Heart Scapular by Barbara Beaumont, Augustine Pub. Co. (October 1, 1986)